Thursday, February 17, 2011

Blue Jays sign Jose Bautista Long Term


I know this post is a little late, but I really wanted to to wait for the dust to settle before diving in (read: I'm lazy). Now that it's basically official, let's take a look at what could either be one of the better signings in Blue Jays history or yet another Wellsian albatross.

I first commented on the potential signing of Jose Bautista a couple of days ago, saying that it would be in the team's best interest to sign their best player to a long term contract now, rather than after the season. My reasoning being that because of their newfound financial flexibility resulting from the Vernon Wells and Alex Rios trades (getting rid of in Rios' case) they could take a chance on signing Bautista and not having the contract hamstring the team should he fall back to earth. Had the Jays waited until next offseason, and Jose put up comparable numbers, we'd be looking at a $100M+ contract. I just didn't see how the reward of waiting justified the risk of losing him to free agency or having to fork over a nine figure contract. That being said, I based my opinion on the assumption that we'd be looking at most a 3 year deal worth $45M, not 6 years and $64M.

I could go on forever jumping back and forth between the positives and negatives about this deal, but instead I'm going to try to summarize my overall thought about the signing in the next paragraph (and a half):

There is not doubt that Jose Baustista is an elite baseball player. Regular baseball players don't typically hit 50+ homeruns, outlier or not. The team is better with him on it, and when it really comes down to it, this contract is not going to make or break the the Jays' long term plans regardless of Jose's performance throughout it. The team has a plethora of talent coming up through the minors who should be impact players in the next couple of years. Those players don't cost much, and will be with the team (barring a trade, injury, etc.) throughout the duration of Bautista's contract. If the team is loaded with young, controllable talent with only a couple veteran players making high salaries, I fail to see how a potentially bad contract or two pushes the payroll too high for Rogers' deep pockets. Their estimated opening day payroll for 2011 is $70M, and that includes the $8M Bautista is receiving this year. Bump that up to $80-85M in 2012 commitments and there is still a ton of flexibility for Anthopolous to sign a free agent or two to put the team over the top. This of course is assuming Beeston hasn't been bullshitting us and that the Jays' payroll can be up to $140M+ when the time is right. That's a big assumption.

I don't condone the spending of money just because it's burning a hole in your pocket, but this deal could very well turn out to be a great one for the Jays. The chances of it failing are equally as high, but that doesn't mean the team just pissed away millions of dollars on some jabroni. They took a calculated risk. Those don't always work out, but thanks to the money they've recently saved and the backing of the richest ownership group in baseball, I believe it was a risk worth taking.

Extra Note:
We still haven't factored in the additional revenue brought in by the Jays with this signing. I agree that a single player doesn't bring people into the stands, but a quality product does. The Jays are a better team with Jose Bautista on it and if he's able to come remotely close to the player he was in 2010 for (at least) two years of the contract he'll help this team contend, add excitement and subsequently bring people to the Rogers Centre. It's very easy to say that "Rogers is a corporation whose sole responsibility is to its shareholders" and hense giving out large contracts to unproven players acts against that ingrained responsibility, but you have to take into account that a portion (how big a portion we are yet to have any idea) of the money spent on Bautista is directly returned to the team in the form of a better product resulting in more fans. I realize this is very difficult to quantify, but for anyone taking the stand that Rogers acted against its core principles as a for-profit corporation by "risking" so much money on an unproven asset has not factored in the fact that Bautista also creates a direct return on investment.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Jose Bautista arbitration hearing pushed back

According to Enrique Rojas of ESPN, and later confirmed by everybody on the internet, the Jays and Jose Bautista have agreed to push back the date of their arbitration hearing four days in order to further discuss a muli-year deal. This is great news for any Jays fan wanting the team to lock up their best player for the next several years as it clearly indicates the sides are working towards a deal.

There are two main schools of thought when it comes to the potential of signing Bautista to a long term(ish) contract. I won't get into the discussion of whether or not the Jays should actually sign him - because that argument has been beaten to a pulp - but instead will focus on whether the team should sign Jose now or wait for him to prove himself for one more year before locking him up.

The first argument centres around the idea that since the Jays unloaded the massive Vernon Wells contract, along with Alex Rios' contract the year before, they now have the financial flexibility to to take a "wait-and-see" approach with Bautista. This argument has been..ugh..argued..at Getting Blanked (which if you're a baseball fan and haven't yet read, do yourself a favour and bookmark the shit out of it). The argument follows that the Jays can now afford to risk having to pay him the massive contract that he no-doubt will command should he produce numbers even close to what he accomplished last year. Instead of getting hamstrung with another large contract committed to an under-producing player (because they want to take advantage of the discount the team would receive by taking a chance on Bautista's ability to replicate last year's performance) they can simply wait until next offseason to better judge Bautista's talent.

I tend to disagree with that argument. A lot. I look at the Jays the newfound financial where-with-all as an opportunity to take a chance on Bautista being able to replicate his 2010 performance. This is all within reason, of course, but if the two sides can agree to a 3-year contract in the $30-$45M range then I (as a Jays fan) would be more than willing to take the chance.

I think we can all agree that it will be tough for Bautista to put up the ridiculous numbers he did last year, but even if his homerun production drops by 20, he's still a 30 homerun guy who adds significant value to the team in other areas with his defensive flexibility and OBP. I'm not saying he's a great defender by any means, but he's a capable defender who is able to be moved around to different positions, allowing the Jays to set their young prospects up for success by being able to place them in the field where they are most comfortable (re: Brett Lawrie).
Even if Bautista's production siginificantly drops, he'll still provide value, and if the team can sign him for three years then with the money saved on the Wells and Rios deals they can afford to pay a bad contract. It's not really all that big of a risk. This all changes, though, if Bautista is looking for a 5+ year contract. If that's the case, then run Alex, run!

I also find it hard to accept as an argument that one more year is enough to solidify Bautista as a legitimate superstar. If the wait-and-see argument takes into account that we don't yet know if Bautista is for real, are we really THAT much more confident in his long-term viabilty after two years of success? Obviously two years is a greater sample size to judge just that, but are the additional at bats really worth what would likely be a contract double the size of what the Jays could sign him for today? I think not.  

It should be an interesting next four days!

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Blue Jays trade Mike Napoli to the Rangers for Frank Francisco

There's got to be something I'm missing here. I usually buy into the whole trust in AA and his legion of minions way of thinking, but I can honestly say this one has me completely stumped.

Aside from being able to unload Vernon Wells' contract on the Angels, I was actually excited about the acquisition of Mike Napoli. He seemed like such a perfect fit to share time at the three positions where the Jays are most uncertain (Catcher, First Base and DH). Instead, Anthopolous has flipped him for another right-handed reliever.

The Jays now have Octavio Dotel, Jon Rauch, Jason Frasor and Frank (don't call me San) Francisco manning the back end of the bullpen - all of whom are right handed. So essentially the Jays have traded from a position of weakness to add to a position of strength (I use the term "strength" more in terms of numbers rather than actual ability). Don't get me wrong, Francisco is actually a pretty good pitcher and is arguably the best of the bunch the Jays now control, but what the two players involved offer the current Jays lineup just doesn't add up.

So let's try to come up with some reasons for the trade, and then proceed to shoot them down:

1) AA is stockpilling above average relievers in hopes of receiving draft picks after the season.
Considering Francisco also accepted the arbitration offer from the Rangers last season due to his Type A free agent ranking, coupled with the fact that he will most likely get a chance to close for the Jays (meaning that ranking isn't likely to change), I can't picture a scenario where he doesn't accept another arbitration offer next year. Sound familiar? Well it should, it's exactly what the team is dealing with in Jason Frasor. No team would give up a first round pick for either pitcher and therefore it makes more sense for them to accept the offer of arbitration. The draft pick logic also doesn't hold true even if Francisco somehow slips to become a Type B free agent (resulting in whatever team signs him not having to give up a first round pick) and the Jays receive a supplementary round pick, because Mike Napoli is still worth more than a sandwich pick. It's a lose/lose.

2) AA is stockpilling above average relievers in hopes of flipping them at the trade deadline. 
Once again, just look at what happened last year to both Frank Francisco and Jason Frasor. No teams are willing to give up much to acquire them mid-season because they know the players will be Type A free agents and will be expensive the next year through arbitration.

3) AA has a separate trade in the works and required a pitcher like Frank Francisco to make it happen. 
There has to be something brewing behind the scenes, but I find it hard to believe that Frank Francisco is the missing piece to any potential future trade AA has cooking. His numbers just aren't different enough from Frasor's to make it make sense. Here are each pitcher's numbers last season:
Frank Francisco: 3.33 K/BB, 0.85 HR/9, .243 AVG, 1.27 WHIP, 3.12 FIP
Jason Frasor: 2.41 K/BB, 0.57 HR/9, .246 AVG, 1.38 WHIP, 3.31 FIP

There are also a couple other issues that comes out of the trade:

1) Why didn't the Jays sign Manny Ramirez?
I have to imagine, given past decisions, that Anthopolous knew ahead of time that he was going to flip Napoli and leave the team with a void at DH (even with Encarnacion on the team, I mean come on..). I realize that it might decrease the leverage the Jays would have in trading Napoli, but fuck, he's still a goddamn good player and I find it hard to believe that if the Rangers really wanted him that the Jays still could have received Francisco in return. Ramirez plus Francisco is greater than Napoli, regardless of the flexibility Napoli provides to the lineup.

2) Is Anthopolous trying to piss the Angels off?
I mentioned in my previous post about the Wells trade that GMs around the league probably took notice at how Anthopolous took advantage of the Angel's apparent desperation and essentially made their GM look ridiculous. My thought was that other team's GMs might think twice about swinging a deal with the crafty Toronto GM. What do you think other General Managers will think now that Anthopolous has fleeced the Angels, then traded the player back into the AL West? I'm assuming AA never mentioned anything about Napoli being flipped into the same division as his former team. That's a greasy move. Greasy like a fox.  

Is this a slight hiccup in what has been an incredibly successful start to Anthopolous' Genera; Manager career? Or does AA have something else in store to prove us all wrong? Only time will tell, I guess.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

More on the Vernon Wells trade

Erect the gold statue

Now that some of the dust has settled after the blockbuster deal that sent the king of all albatrosses to the LA Angels it's time o do a little more analysis. In the interest of keeping my thoughts together and organized, I present to you the Glory Jays' Top Eleven Vernon Wells Trade Reaction Contemplations. Kind of rolls of the toungue, doesn't it?

1) The fact that no money is involved and the Jays are actually acquiring useable pieces in Mike Napoli and Juan Rivera makes me love Alex Anthopolous even more. He's literally done the impossible in ridding the team of Wells' contract, and got something positive in return.

2) I guess this means that Rajai Davis will be the team's everyday centre fielder, which I'm actually ok with (for now). Davis sucked last year, no doubt, but his -7.1 UZR in centre field was basically the same as Wells (-7.0 UZR). The difference being that Davis' UZR in centre field in the previous two years were positive, while Wells put up -21.8 and -18.4 UZR in 2008 and 2009, respectively. So I think it's safe to conclude that Rajai Davis is a better centre fielder than Vernon. He obviously doesn't provide the same power potential that Wells does (I'll let you look those numbers up), but if he can return anywhere close to the OBP he put up in 2009 he'll be a more than capable lead-off hitter with base-stealing speed, which is something the Jays lacked (power was not).

3) This deal obviously frees up a shitload of money, which could potentially be used to lock up Joe Bautista long term. I still don't know if I buy into this train of thought, as it feels as though they would be falling right back into the trap that AA just managed to wriggle the team out of. Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge Bautista fan, but if he lights it up again next year he'll likely command a massive salary that could hand-cuff the team once his performance inevitably declines with age. If by the trade deadline Bautista is mashing like he did last year, I'd expect AA to trade him if the right package of blue-chip prospects is offered, rather than look to sign him long term.

4) The Jays receiving Mike Napoli in the deal gives the team a highly versatile and productive player which creates a great deal of options for them. He can be used as a platoon catcher with JPA, a platoon first baseman with Adam Lind (Napoli is a right handed hitter who hits lefties well, while Lind is not and does not), and/or a platoon DH with Encarnacion. The Jays also now control a player who could become very attractive to teams in the playoff hunt at the trade deadline next year.

5) I was glancing over some LA Angels blogs and forums last night to see what the general reactions were to the trade. At first, Angles fans seemed confused but somewhat optimistic because they (rightfully so) assumed that money would be coming LA's way to offset some of Vernon's contract. As I scrolled through the discussions, it basically turned into a black hole of disbelief. Blue Jays forums were jam packed with disbelief as well, only it was more like a teenager getting laid by his friend's hot mom, and pinching himself to make sure it wasn't a (wet) dream.

6) I found it interesting to compare this transaction to that of Alex Rios going to the Chicago White Sox. On the one hand we have Vernon Wells, whose contract dwarfs Rios' and is 3 years older than him, being traded to the Angles for a positive return. On the other hand, Rios was given away for free to Chicago just to rid the team of his contract. This trade just gets better and better, while I continue swooning over AA.

7) There's no doubt that in the short term, the Jays are worse off without Wells in the line-up, which is something that maybe Anthopolous is banking on. Toronto will have only $17.4M in payroll commitments in 2012 and will likely make a run at some high-end free-agents. If the Jays finish in the bottom half of the standings in 2011 their first round draft pick is protected and the team won't have to give it up if/when they make a splash in the free agent market. Pujols anyone?
8) As Keith Law pointed out, this deal wreaks of deperation on the Angels part. I'm assuming the majority of GMs around baseball would agree and may be hesitant to pick up the phone the next time Anthopolous calls, seeing as how he so opportunistically took advantage of LA's depseration.

9) I read on an Angels blog that what LA has essentially done is give away Mike Napoli and sign Juan Rivera to a 4-year $85M contract. While I don't necessarily agree that Rivera and Wells are the same player statistically (and neither does WAR graphs), it's still a pretty damn funny way to look at it.

10) Given the amount of money remaining on Wells' contract, he'll make a higher per year salary than what Carl Crawford is making in Boston. Granted Crawford is signed for 7 years as opposed to Vernon's 4, but this really has to sting for Angels fans. I think we should all give a collective "THANK YOU!" to Carl Crawford and Adrian Beltre for spurning the Angels and signing elsewhere. There's no way this deal gets done, without a boatload of cash going LA's way, if either of those players sign with the Angels.

11) Some quick comments from MLBtraderumors.com regarding the trade:
  • Keith Law points out that with the money Toronto saved in the trade, the Jays could become very good, very fast. I tend to agree.
  • Richard Griffin tweeted that this deal might already be Anthopolous' best ever. That's impossible to say, Richard, but it is a damn good notch in his belt. 
  • Ken Rosenthal wonders if the Jays would have caved and sent $20M+ to the Angels had it been necessary. As you'll see in point "8" of a previous post of mine, I would have been willing to eat even more. 
  • Along the same lines, a long time talent evaluator told ESPN's Buster Olney that the Jays would have had to take on at least $30M in salary to make the deal remotely even. 
Have a great Saturday night!

Friday, January 21, 2011

Breaking News: Vernon Wells traded to LA Angels for Mike Napoli and Juan Rivera

My thoughts exactly, Vernon.

According to Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports, the Toronto Blue Jays have somehow just unloaded Vernon Wells and the remainder of his 7 year $126 Million contract - which still consists of a total $86M over the next four freakin' years!!! - to the LA Angels in exchange for Mike Napoli and Juan Rivera.

After my friend Charlie sent me a text letting me know about the deal, I nearly kissed the Hungarian woman sitting across from me on the Go Train, but before we plan to erect a solid gold statue of Alex Anthopolous at 1 Blue Jays Way, let's wait to hear what all the details are.

I've read in the Twitter world and heard on a couple blogs that were quicker to the draw than me (which, considering my last post was over a week ago, really isn't that impressive) that rumors were swirling indicating that Kyle Drabek was involved in the deal. Shipping off their #1 prospect to save money on the remainder of Wells' contract seems against the common theme that AA and Rogers have been pounding into us that they're willing to spend money on high-end, young, controlable talent. For now, I'm going to chaulk those rumors up to just that: Rumors.

The deal is still pending physicals. And by that I mean Vernon Wells is taking a physical since I'm pretty sure the Angels could ship over the rotting corpses of Mike Napoli and Juan Rivera - who combined will make about half of Vernon's salary next year - and the Jays would still gladly accept the trade.

The financial details have not yet been revealed, so it's tough to do a complete analysis on the deal, other than HOO-FUCKING-RAY!  More to come on this trade once the details work themselves out.

What a great start to the weekend...

Friday, January 14, 2011

Yankees sign Rafael Soriano

So the Yankees have finally found someone this offseason who was willing to take their money, and it came in the form of shut-down closer - ugh, I mean set-up man - Rafael Soriano. The Yankees have agreed to pay Soriano $35M for the next three years to be the set up man for Mariano Rivera for the next two at least. Soriano can also opt out of the contract after year 1 or year 2. Before getting into what this means in a baseball sense for the Yankess (and subsequently the AL East), can we all marvel in the greatness that is Scott Boras? I know he's a dick, but goddamn is he good at his job.


Somehow Boras managed to make Soriano the 5th highest paid reliever in baseball, in a market that had seemingly dried up, and to be a set-up man for fucks sake. Soriano's annual average salary ($11.67M) trails only Rivera, Brad Lidge, Joe Nathan and Francisco Rodriguez - all of whom are closers.

Another interesting twist in this news is the fact that only days ago Brian Cashman stated that the team will not give up its 2011 first round pick to sign any of the remaining free agents. Unless those words were used simply as a negotiating tactic (which for obvious reason didn't fucking work), it looks like Cashman may be losing the confidence of those above him. After missing out Cliff Lee, Carl Crawford and Jayson Werth, I can't imagine the remaining Steinbrenners are too happy with their golden boy and perhaps forced his hand on this acquisition.

There is no doubt that this signing makes the Yankees better immediately, and takes a lot of pressure off their young (see: shitty) staff. If the Yankees are in the lead by the time the 8th inning rolls around I can't imagine them not winning 99% of those games. What this signing does, however, is once again mortgage a portion of New York's future. If you compare the Yankees offseason to that of the Boston Red Sox, the outcomes are night and day. Boston not only acquired the better free agents/trade acquisition they did so while actually upgrading their draft positions this year. Carl Crawford and Adrian Gonzalez, plus the draft compensations they will receive from Victor Martinez signing in Detroit and Adrian Beltre signing in Texas greatly outway what they had to give up in prospects and draft picks to acquire the two superstars.

Then there's Tampa Bay who now possess 3 first round draft picks and 6 supplemental draft picks in what is being widely regarded as the deepest draft in years. That's how you compete in the AL East on a shoestring budget, and that's what Anthopolous is trying to do with the Blue Jays - except with more cash available when needed.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Alomar gets into the Hall of Fame, and it's about time.

Yesterday, Roberto Alomar was awarded his rightful place in the Baseball Hall of Fame, after being snubbed the year before by the Baseball Writers of American (BBWAA), and he'll be entering as a Toronto Blue Jays. Let's first take a quick look at Alomar's numbers over his career:
  • Career .300 average, .371 OBP, .443 SLG
  • 210 home runs, 1134 RBI, 1508 runs scored, 2724 base hits
  • 474 stolen bases
  • Selected to 12 All-Star teams, starting 9 of them at 2B
  • 10 Gold Glove awards
  • 2 World Series Championship with the Toronto Blue Jays
Looking at those numbers, there's no way Alomar shouldn't have been a first ballot Hall of Famer. Which leads me the general argument of this entire post - that hall of fame voting is ass-backwards. For one thing, the Baseball Writers are around the players more often than anybody else. While it's a good thing for the voters to be well-informed about the players they're voting on, at what point do their personal opinions of the players influence their ability to objectively vote on whether or not they deserve to be in the Hall of Fame.

Admittedly, Alomar wasn't always a model citizen. He spat in the face of umper John Hirshbeck and had unprotected sex with his girlfriend while supposedly knowing he was HIV positive (that one's up for debate). But the fact of the matter is, his baseball numbers are more than adequate to have been elected to the Hall on his first go, and those are the only factors that should be taken into account.  

There are writers out there who have taken this opportunity to compare Alomar's shortcomings to those of players who have taken steroids. The problem with that argument is that for all of Alomar's faults, none of them were directly related to his ability to play the game at a high level. Steroids on the other hand play a large part in the numbers a player puts up over his career. I don't believe, however, in the Baseball Writers (BBWAA) taking it upon themselves to grandstand about players who are suspected of using steroids (ie. Mark McGuire). It is not their job to punish players based on allegations rather than proof, and until proof is obtained, any player suspected of using steroids should have just as much of an opportunity as someone who is not.   

A couple last points about it taking Alomar two tries to make it to Cooperstown:  If personal feelings had nothing to do with Alomar not being a first ballot Hall of Famer, how is it possible that Andre Dawson was elected last year while Alomar was not? Dawson's career line is .279/.323/.482, he had 8 gold gloves and 8 all-star appearances. Aside from SLG%, Alomar's numbers are better across the board. 

Last year, Alomar received 73.7% of the votes (75% is required to enter the Hall). That equates to 428 of a possible 581 votes. This year, he received 90%, or 523 votes. For the sake of this entire blog post and argument, wouldn't it be fucking great to hear what changed for the 95 voters who decided Alomar was more deserving of entering the Hall of Fame this year as opposed to last? His baseball numbers didn't change, so I think it's safe to assume that after the prestige of being a first ballot Hall of Famer was taken away from Alomar, those voters felt like they did their part in punishing Alomar for his past, and that was now worthy of entering the Hall. As if it was their responsibility.   

For more on the subjectivity of Hall of Fame voting, check out this article over at fangraphs. I'd love to hear the BBWAA explain this one.

Jerry Howarth - as usual - says it best. If you are a fan of the Jays, a fan of Roberto Alomar and a fan of nostalgia listen to this interview.

Last thing: People are awesome.
 

Monday, January 3, 2011

Blue Jays sign Chad Cordero

You know it's a slow time in the baseball world when Chad Cordero gets a headline, but so she goes..
According to MLBtraderumors.com, the Jays have agreed to sign reliever Chad Cordero, who will presumably be competing for a spot in the the team's bullpen this year. The terms haven't yet been released, but I'd assume that it's not for more than one year and $1M.

Cordero was dominant in his first three seasons in the majors, actually accumulating 47 saves in 2005 (the same year he made the All-Start team and received Cy Young and MVP votes). In 2006 he finished the year with a 3.19 ERA, 1.105 WHIP, 2.7 BB/9 and 8.5 SO/9. In 2007 his numbers remained respectable with a 3.36 ERA, 1.387 WHIP, 3.5 BB/9 and 7.4 SO/9.

He then had shoulder surgery and has been pretty shitty in the majors ever since. His numbers in the minors last year were good, but that success hasn't yet translated to the majors since going under the knife. Either way, it's worth taking a flyer on the guy - as long as the cost is minimal - in hopes of him returning to anywhere near his old numbers. Not bloody likely though.

On another note:

There are multiple rumours going around that Adrian Beltre is close to signing with the Texas Rangers, and I wanted to highlight how this will affect the Jays. On one hand, it's a good thing if the Rangers sign Beltre as that means the LA Angels won't, resulting in the Jays receiving the Angels 2nd round draft pick next year instead of their third (since Beltre is a higher ranked free-agent than Scott Downs). On the other hand, the Rangers' first round pick isn't protected which means the Red Sox will receive Texas' first round draft pick next year. If the Angels sign Beltre then the Red Sox receive a 2nd rounder from the Angels while the Jays would receive a third rounder. So (assuming Beltre is going to sign with either the Angels or the Rangers) the question becomes: would you rather the Jays receive a 2nd round draft pick from the Angels and the Red Sox receive a 1st round pick from the Rangers; or that the Angels (whose 1st round pick is protected) sign Beltre and the Red Sox only get a 2nd round choice for Beltre while the Jays get a 3rd rounder? 

Based on the supposed drop off in talent between the 1st round and each subsequent round, I'd have to think that it's in the best interest of the Jays if the Red Sox don't get another 1st round selection (remember, they already have Detroit's from losing Victor Martinez) as it all becomes a bit of a crapshoot after the 1st round anyways, and the difference between the 2nd and 3rd rounds can be minimal.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

I'm back! Oh, and the Blue Jays sign Octavio Dotel

After a week or so of speculation, the Jays have officially signed Octavio Dotel to a one year deal worth $2.75M with a $3.75M club option for 2012 and a $750K buyout. Imagine getting paid $750K because the team doesn't want you? Ah what a life...

There's been a lot of mixed reactions to the acquisition and to be honest I'm still a little bit on the fence about it. Looking from a strictly dollars-for-talent viewpoint it doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Dotel will be making closer's money next year, and based on his lefty/righty splits alone, it seems like a fucking horrible idea to give the closer reigns to him. Let's take a look at his career splits against right and left handed batters:

Lefties:
  • WHIP: 1.49
  • K/9: 9.44
  • BB/9: 5.59
  • AVG: .236
  • FIP: 4.66
Righties:
  • WHIP: 0.99
  • K/9: 12.28
  • B/9: 2.70
  • AVG: .196
  • FIP: 2.95
If those don't look like righty specialist numbers, then I really don't know what do.

There are other things to consider with the acquisition, however. For one, it should be safe to assume that Dotel will retain his Type B status for next year (especially if he gets some closing opportunities) and will earn the Jays a supplemental draft pick next year if they decline his option. Which they will. The other thing to consider is that th Blue Jays - and Rogers - apparently have an endless supply of money, so why the fuck do we (as fans) care about them overpaying for a a pitcher who should be used strictly against right-handed batters. If he can continue his dominance against righties then the team will have an incredibly valuable option coming out of the bullpen, and if we're to believe what we've been told abut Rogers' willingness to spend, then Dotel's salary shouldn't be an issue regardless of whether or not he's closing next year.

There's little doubt that Dotel will be given an opportunity to be te Jays' everyday closer next year, but over the course of the season those career numbers will start to show. Let's hope John Farrell and Alex Anthopolous are prepared to use the veteran reliever the way he should be used, and avoid a Brian Tallet-esque disaster like last year.

Friday, December 24, 2010

The ten ways the Jays would have been legitimate contenders in 2011

Every now and then it's fun to escape from reality and imagine a world where everything works out just the way you want it to. Here at the Glory Jays we like to try and keep a level head when analyzing the goings-on in the baseball world so we can make rational and informed opinions. But it's Christmas (or close enough) that we've decided to treat ourselves to an early Christmas present and list the ten things the Jays could have done so far this offseason to have vaulted them into the realm of real fucking contenders to win the World Series. Some in the list were actual possibilities, some not so much. I'm also taking into assumption that (within reason...ish) money isn't a concern.

So without further adieu:

1) Sign Adam Dunn to play first base
It's crazy to actually say that an athlete making $56M over 4 years is a bargain, but those are the times we live in (or rather MLB players live in), and that signing was a fucking steal. There's almost no risk for the White Sox as Dunn has been the same player year in and year out for basically his entire career. He hit at least 40 homeruns per year from 2004 to 2008, and 38 in 2009 and 2010. His OBP has never dropped below .350 and his career OBP is .381. He's no star defensively, but if it would have taken the Jays to offer $60M over 4 years to sign him, I would have done it.

2) Keep Shaun Marcum
This is a no brainer if you're looking to legitimately contend in 2011. In the real world, the Jays are rebuilding and I like the trade for Brett Lawrie, but obviously you don't trade one of your top starting pitchers for a prospect when the goal is to win now.

3) Sign Cliff Lee
This is where I start to deviate into fantasy land, much like the Tao of Stieb did in a post earlier this month. I can't think of any real reasons why Cliff Lee would have signed in Toronto unless the Jays had already made all the moves I've listed (plus what I am going to list) in this post, and if they threw an obscene amount of money at him. He obviously had a hard-on for Phillidelphia, regardless of the fact that they shipped him off to make room for Halladay last off-season, and convincing him to come to the Jays would have been next to impossible. But give him $200M over 7 years and he signs. Ahhhh money solves everything.

4) Trade for Dan Uggla
The rift-raft the Braves sent to Florida for Uggla made me really question why Anthopolous couldn't make a deal for the slugging second baseman, The only reason I thought of was that he didn't see him with the team long term and didn't want the distraction of negotiating (or not negotiating) a contract extension with him. But that's a lame excuse, even if it wasn't just fabricated by me two seconds ago. Either way, for the Jays to have truly been contenders in 2011 I would have made the trade, and moved him or Hill to third base.

5) Give the reigns to JP Arencibia
Let the kid play. There really weren't many better options on the free-agent market, and this team I'm building in fantasy land is so ridiculous(ly good) and as long as JPA doesn't forget how to catch a ball we should be ok. Plus there's Molina backing him up just in case.
Note: Even though I'm throwing money around like it's going out of style, I still wouldn't have matched 3 years and $18M for John Buck or 4 years and $50M for Victor "soon-to-be-DH" Martinez. That, my friends, is ri-fucking-diculous.

6) Make the trade for Justin Upton
I realize Arizona was really just testing the market, and wasting everyone's time, but seeing as how I just threw $200M at Cliff Lee, rationality has gone out the window. Offer Drabek, Lind, Stewart, Hech and D'Arnaud and see if he bites. And he will. Because I say so.

7) Sign Manny Ramirez to DH
Manny is in serious decline, but he's still on on-base machine. If we can find a way to get him back on the juice, and undetected, for 2011 he'd be a force at DH.

8) Do whatever it takes to get rid of Vernon Wells
At this point in his career, what is Vernon Wells worth? Would you be comfortable with $10M per year? Less? More? Let's use $10M per year as a benchmark and assume other teams view it the same way. Trade him to a willing partner and eat 50% + of his contract to make it happen. Remember, we have Justin Upton now and need to make room.

9) Build a crazy good bullpen
Sign Rafael Soriano and Bobby Jenks, and bring back Scott Downs. That ought to do it.

10) Bring back the $82 Jays Pass
In case Anthopolous was wrong in assuming that fans will return to the ballpark once the team is winning.

Starting Line Up:
1. Escobar SS
2. Snider LF
3. Upton CF
4. Bautista RF
5. Dunn 1B
6. Uggla 3B
7. Ramirez DH
8. Hill 2B
9. JP Arencibia C

Starting Rotation:
1. Cliff Lee
2. Ricky Romero
3. Shaun Marcum
4. Brandon Morrow
5. Brett Cecil

Merry Christmas Everyone!

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Richard Griffin, still wrong.

Yesterday we made reference to a Richard Griffin article where he proclaims that Alex Anthopolous was schooled by veteran (and Canadian - like that fucking matters) GM Doug Melvin of the Milwaukee Brewers. A few blogs and forums around the Blue Jays' blogosphere were a little up in arms about the insinuation, and the article became somewhat of a joke when Jeff Blair of the Globe and Mail and Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports pointed out that the Jays were told early in the offseason that Greinke would not waive his no trade clause to come to Toronto, thereby making the statement that AA was "schooled" unjustified.

Well Griffin is back at it again today, trying to justify his previous article with this piece in the Star this morning. The article says that AA wouldn't agree to send Snider and Drabek plus others in return for Greinke and that is the reason the deal didn't happen. As Griffing puts it:

He stepped aside, willing to re-enter the fray if Royals GM Dayton Moore ever called back and lowered the asking price. Yes, the Jays were on Greinke's no-trade list, but so were the Brewers.

The Brewers were also on his no-trade list BEFORE the Jays sent Marcum to Milwaukee and made it clear to the league that they were prepared to risk their future for a shot at the division now. Which is exactly what Greinke was looking for. It also couldn't hurt Greinke to dominate the senior circuit for a couple years before he hits free-agency, as his numbers will no doubt be a hell of a lot better in the NL Central than they would be after 2 years in the AL East.

In Rosenthal's article he also names that the Jays were willing to part with Adeiny Hechavarria, Anthony Gose, one of JP Arencibia or Travis D'Arnaud and a young pitcher. I realize that I'm a little bias here, but those prospects look a lot better than what Milwaukee had to send to KC in return for their Ace pitcher.

I wanted to touch on (make fun of) a couple other ridiculous points Griffin makes in this morning's article. I think what he was trying to do was compare the teams that are making a push for winning now to the scenario the Jays are currently in. But just like Monday's article where he compares AA to a texas hold 'em player who likes to see every flop, the thoughts become so convoluted that the reader (me) is left wondering what the hell he's trying to get across. Anyway here's a section of the article that I found particularly retarded:

The three biggest superstar free-for-alls of the current off-season - Jayson Werth, Cliff Lee and Zack Greinke - were all won by suprise teams, believed to be long shots at best.

All three - the Nationals, Phillies and Brewers - are teams that had observed the Giants' unlikely World Series win and decided the future of contending is now, that rebuilding is day-to-day.

For the sad-sack Nationals, signing the free-agent outfielder Werth for seven years and $126 million while he was courted by the Red Sox, among others, was all about contending as soon as their prized No. 1 overall picks are ready for prime time.

So according to this reasoning, the Nationals signed a 32-year-old outfielder in the hopes that when their top prospects are ready for the big leagues he will still be there (and still be good) to help win a Championship. Does anyone else see how backwards that argument is? Why not instead save their money, and spend it on an available free-agent when those prospects are actually contributing in the MLB? Sound like a familiar plan? It should because that's exactly what the Jays are waiting to do.

And when the hell did Carl Crawford stop being one of the top superstars who were available this offseason? You'd think that since he signed the largest contract of the offseason that he sould be included in the argument. But what do I know.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Minor league signings. Hooray!

The Jays announced six minor league signings today, including RHP Winston Abreu, catcher Ryan Budde, LHP Sean Henn, LHP Mike Hinckley, RHP Brian Stokes, and former Oriole outfielder Corey Patterson.

Patterson is the most notable of all the signings and will undoubtedly push the Jays over the top in the AL East. Seems like the reason why Brewers' GM Doug Melvin was so easily able to "school" Alex Anthopolous while acquiring Zack Greinke from the Royals was because AA was spending far too much time contemplating minor league depth moves. I'd give a greater explanation of what that painfully sarcastic sentence was in reference to, but instead I'll take the lazy way out and direct you over to the Score's Getting Blanked for a much more in depth analysis of the Richard Griffin article in the Star this morning to which I am referring.

As for the minor league signings, Corey Patterson is an interesting, if not a horribly under-fucking-whelming one. I can see the logic in the signing, though, as it provides the Jays with another outfield option in case Jose Bautista is moved to third base (which seems increasingly more likely with each passing day) and if they aren't comfortable with Rajai Davis as their everyday left/right fielder. Essentially, based solely on their batting stats, Corey Patterson is the poor man's Rajai Davis - which doesn't bode all that well, but he is a decent backup plan in case any of the outfielders get injured or if Davis struggles like he did last year.

Defensively, both Patterson and Davis excel in right field (particularly in comparison to their left field stats) as evidenced by their ultimate zone ratings (UZR). Patterson's right field, home/away, UZR/150 over his career is 198.9/15.1 and -10.4/3.3 in right field. Rajai Davis' right field (home/away) UZR/150 over his career is 21.1/5.5 and -16.5/-16.2 in left field. Seems like if Bautista is going to be stationed at third base, we can expect Snider to be in left field and Davis (with Patterson backing him up) in right field. It's not a signing to get excited about really, but it's also one that costs nothing, risks nothing, and still provides some insurance for the ball club.

The rest of the signings are basically just fliers on guys who've shown some success in the minors but not much in the big leagues. Maybe one of them turns into the next Scott Downs who the Jays picked up for nothing and who turned into one of their most reliable relievers. And if not, who the fuck cares, like I said earlier it costs nothing and risks nothing.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Greinke is taking his talents to Milwaukee

The Kansas City Royals have finally shipped their disgruntled ace out of town, and he's heading to the Milwaukee Brewers. Going the other way are four propsects, two of which have MLB experience. Considering the Jays were rumoured to be interested in acquiring Greinke I figured it would be worthwhile to give some stats on the four players heading to Kansas City so we can all do what you know we are going to do and compare them to any Jays propsects that could have been used to acquire Greinke.

Lorenzo Cain was considered one of the Brewers top 10 propects heading into the 2010 season. Thecentre fielder hit .317/.402/.432 across two minor league levels before getting the call up to the majors. In only 148 plate appearances he hit a very respectable .306/.348/.415. He's considered mainly a gap hitter with not a tonne of power, but exceptional speed. He stole 33 bases in 37 attempts between the minors and majors.

Alcides Escobar is a shortstop who was considered the Brewers top prospect before the 2010 season. He spent the entire year in the majors and accumulated a very unimpressive .235/.288/.326 slash line. He is, however, considered a defensive master and a large portion of his vlaue lies in his glove.

Jeremy Jeffress was ranked as the 3rd best pitching prospect in the Brewers system last year. He missed significant amounts of time between the 2009 and 2010 seasons for repeatedly testing positive for marijuana. It doesn't seem to be affecting his pitching, though, as his fastball consistently touches 100 mph.

Lastly, Jake Odorizzi. He was ranked as the Brewers top pitching prospect last year, was also considered the best high school pitcher in the 2008 draft and is likely the prospect with the highest ceiling in this trade. He's only 20 years old and pitched to a 3.43 ERA in Class A last year.

I think it's pretty safe to say that the rumoured package centred around Drabek and Snider would have gotten the deal done with the Royals. From strictly looking at the numbers (as I've never actually seen any of these guys play) I would take Snider or Drabek over all four of them, and Anthopolous did very well to not be willing to part with those guys. 

Apparently the Royals were looking for both quantity over quality and were also looking to fill holes in their system at shortstop and centre field. I've never agreed with GMs making trades strictly to fill "holes" in their farm system instead of trading for the highest talent. That talent can always be flipped at a later time to acquire the position player you require.

From the Jays perspective, they managed to snag Brett Lawrie fom the Brewers before the Royals were able to get their hands on him. There's really no doubt that he would have been included in the Greinke trade were he still available, and from a talent level is on par or above any of the players KC acquired in the trade. If you want to look back even further, you can compare this trade to the Roy Halladay trade last year. Which propects would you rather have on the Jays? I'd take Drabek, D'Arnaud and Gose any day for one year of Roy Halladay over what the Royals were able to obtain for two years of Greinke. Well done again, sir Alex.
 

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Blue Jays Re-Acquire Edwin Encarnacion

Well, Alex Anthopolous is a man of his word. He said he was looking for a 1B/DH type who could give the team some flexibility and he's done just that. Can't say I saw this coming, though. In a surprise move, the Jays have re-signed third-baseman Edwin Encarnacion to a 1-year $2.5M contract to the be team's 1B/DH. The contract includes a club option at $3.5M the following year.

As much as I hated watching EE airmail throws, trot down the first base line and disappear for weeks at a time at the plate, I don't necessarily hate this pickup. Aside from his 21 homeruns last year, his numbers in Toronto have been nothing short of a shit show. His slash line last year was .244/.305./482 and the year before that .240/.306/.442. But he isn't that far removed from his most productive years while in Cincinnati where in 2008 he hit .251/.340/.466 with 26 HR. I'd take that any day for $2.5M.

Then there's his glove, which obviously leaves much to be desired as his career -11.5 UZR/150 can attest, but as any Jays fan can tell you, the majority of his defensive shittiness resides in throwing, so having him at 1B or DH takes that negative out of the equation. Although, I can't imagine that he won't be shuffled over to third base at some point during the season for a few spot starts, and on those days it should be fun painful to see him make Adam Lind earn his paycheck at 1B.

The other thing I want to touch on is now teams and fans seem to be under the impression that 1B is a black hole where they can hide terrible defensive players. I get that Overbay's time in Toronto had run its course, and it was a time for change, but I have a feeling all those "fans" who felt it was their obligation to call the Fan590 and voice their displeasure towards Overbay ever so eloquently will be wishing he was still around when we have the dynamic duo of Adam Lind and Edwin Encarnacion manning the cold corner.

So what does this mean for the rest of the offseason in Blue Jay land? Well, if AA is telling the truth and plans to play EE at 1B/DH and isn't just using this as a bargaining tactic, it's safe to assume the Derek Lee rumours will now end. There's no place for him now. Same goes for Manny Ramirez. There is, however, a hole at third base (or in the the outfield if Bautista is moved to third) that the team will have to address. I don't usually advocate bringing up prospects prematurely as it can not only damage the player's confidence but it also wastes a year of eligibility on a season where the team doesn't figure to compete for a playoff spot. However, I don't think the Blue Jays' shinny new prospect is lacking in confidence (if anything he could use being knocked down a peg), and if you think this team is aiming to to truly compete in 2012 why not start developing the team's top position prospect at the major league level now? Just a thought...

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Delusional Yankee followers

While I was scrolling through MLBtraderumors today I came across an article written by Joel Sherman of the NY Post  that I thought was pretty telling of front-runner Yankee fans and media. The general theme of the article is that the Yankees will be a "deeper, less top-heavy team without Cliff Lee", since they can now allocate the money they would have spent on Lee to other places including the bullpen and a 4th outfielder.

Let me first point out just how ridiculous the notion is that if the Yankees had of spent $20-$25M per year on Cliff Lee they wouldn't have enough left to spend on extra arms in the bullpen or a 4th fucking outfielder. Those two relievers and a utility man would have put them over the top. Not Sabathia, Texeira, Burnett, Jeter, Rivera, or A-Rod's contracts.

Next on Sherman's Pulitzer prize worthy article was stating that the Yankees have one of the best farm systems in the MLB, and a solid young "core" that includes Robinson Cano and uhhhh...

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Things to take away from Cliff Lee signing in Philadelphia

Christmas came a little early last night for Jays fans, and I guess Phillies fans too, when Cliff Lee signed in Philadelphia. Aside from the awesomeness that is now the Phillies rotation which now includes Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee, Roy Oswalt, Cole Hamels and Joe Blanton (until he's traded that is), this is fantastic news for the Jays as one of the games' top pitchers won't be making a home in New York (or even the American Fucking League!) for the next 7 years.

What's really refreshing about the entire scenario is that a professional athlete, seemingly at the top of his game, took less money and less years to play in the city he wants to play for. The fact that it's the Yankees that he spurned is just icing on the cake. For some reason, though, I do actually feel some sympathy for the Rangers who seemed to have pulled out all the stops to sign Lee. So I figured we can take a quick look at the options for the Rangers moving forward:
  • They've been linked to Zack Greinke (almost) as much as the Blue Jays, so this is very much still an option for the team. You'd have to think that the asking price for Greinke just got a little steeper now that Lee is off the market, and the Rangers' desperation is seeping out Nolan Ryan's pores.
  • There's been talk of moving Neftali Feliz from the closer's role to the starting rotation. If the Rangers buy into the notion of 'closer by committee' this could be a great option. If they want to keep a bonafide closer in the mix, there's always Rafael Soriano too.
  • They can say 'fuck it' as far as adding pitching and look at adding some offense through the trade market or by signing someone like Adrian Beltre. Their starting rotation without Lee is still respectable with CJ Wilson (3.39 ERA), Tommy Hunter (3.88 ERA), Colby Lewis (3.48 ERA), Scott Feldman (5.48 ERA) and Derek Holland (4.19 ERA).

Monday, December 13, 2010

How MLB payrolls affect teams' chances of winning

There's been a lot of talk lately about the need to institute a salary cap in the MLB, particularly after the signings of Carl Crawford and Jayson Werth, the potential extension signed by Adrian Gonzalez, and the inevitable contract signed by Cliff Lee. It really doesn't seem like teams are playing on a level playing field when other teams like the Yankees can afford to spend whatever it takes to field a winner. What a seemingly endless supply of money also does is it allows teams to take chances on free-agents that smaller market teams can't take. Hell, why not sign Cliff Lee to a 7 year $160 million contract even if you only expect him to be good for another 4 years if the money really doesn't matter?

I've heard people argue that payrolls don't play as big of a role in the success of teams as one might think, and the San Francisco Giants' World Series victory seems to be the rallying cry around this school of thought. Here's the problem with that, though: The Giants had a higher payroll than every other team in its division last year. Any baseball fan tell you that it's a game of sample sizes. This is why they play 162 games a year, and why the payroll of a team is significant when related to the payrolls of the other teams within its division. Any team can conceivably win once they make it to the playoffs because the sample sizes are so much smaller. Kansas City could beat the Yankees in a best out of five series, but I sure as shit wouldn't bet on them having a better record over the course of a season.

Sunday, December 12, 2010

Some stray thoughts from around the MLB

With nothing really exciting happening in baseball world right now, I figured I'd scour the internet (ie. scroll through MLBtraderumors.com) looking for any interesting tidbits going on right now. Here they are:
  • Cliff Lee still hasn't decided where he will sign, but apparently the Yankees are growing increasingly pessimistic about their chances. What seemed like a slam dunk only weeks ago for the Yanks has now tilted in the Rangers' favour. According to Brian Costa of The Wall Street Journal, one reason why the Rangers are able to offer similar money to Lee could have something to do with the fact that Texas doesn't have a state income tax. So they could effectively offer the same money to Lee for less. On the other hand, Lee would presumably make way more money on endorsement deals in New York. Either way, he's going to be one rich bastard, so who really cares.
  • Apparently the Red Sox were the only team to discuss Justin Upton with the Diamondbacks at the Winter Meetings, but "scoffed" at the notion of including Daniel Bard in the trade discussions. Really? That's what killed the trade talks?
  • Six teams are interested in Derek Lee, including the Blue Jays. This would be a great pickup for the Jays.
  • According to ESPN's Buster Olney, the Jays have no interest in including Drabek and Snider in a trade for Zack Greinke. No shit.
  • Baseball time in Arlington has an interesting read comparing a potential Cliff Lee deal to the one A-Rob signed with the Rangers in 2001.
That's all for now. I'm hoping to get a much more deserving post up tomorrow!

Thursday, December 9, 2010

More on the Carl Crawford acquisition

I feel like a child who's been acting out and is now being punished by his parents. A lot of Jays fans (myself included) really felt as though the Jays were beginning to turn that corner, that maybe they were a piece or two away from really competing in the AL East. Then out comes the wooden spoon.

Last night, when the Boston Red Sox announced they had signed Carl Crawford to a seven year-$142 million contract, any illusions of grandeur came crashing back to reality. The Red Sox aren't regressing like many of us hoped and you can fucking bet the Yankees won't stand idly by as Boston builds the most dangerous line-up in the league. What I hope does come out of all this, though, is that the Jays stick to their plan of building for sustainable success, because they won't be spending $20 million a year on a player anytime soon (and yes I realize Vernon Wells is making between $21-$23 million each of the next 4 years - but I consider that a blip in the radar, and one that has hamstrung the jays since it was signed). They need to build from within much like the Tampa Bay Rays have done the past few years, and hopefully when the time comes to either re-sign one of their stars or bring in a free-agent to put them over the top, Rogers is there to put their money where their mouths are.

Enough of my preaching. Here are some of the thoughts and reactions from around the MLB to the Crawford signing:
  • The Angels and Rangers, who were both "in hard" on Carl Crawford may now be able to make a stronger push for Cliff Lee. Gay.
  • The Red Sox interest in Scott Downs may increase as they won't have to surrender their 1st round pick. That will now be going to Tampa Bay, while the Jays would receive the Red Sox 2nd rounder . This signing just keeps getting better for Jays fans.
  • With a crowded outfield, Boston is basically out of the running for Magglio Ordonez. I'd still like to see Ordonez on a one year contract in Toronto, but I'm so discouraged right now I really don't care.
  • Apparently several AL executives feel as though Crawford's athleticism will be wasted in left field at Fenway.

Carl Crawford signs with Boston

It's late so I'll wait for tomorrow to analyze this acquisition. But holy fuck the AL East just got a whole lot tougher. Remember when we were all talking about the Red Sox, Yankees, and Rays taking major steps back this year? Maybe the people crying about losing Marcum for a blue chip prospect are starting to see why it's so important to build for sustained success through acquiring high ceiling talent in this division. Especially for a team that can't spend with the big boys.